Monday, February 21, 2011

Why Ashraf Mansour Should Go

*Edit: for those unaware, this post has been sent directly to Dr. Ashraf Mansour and members of the Guc's  board of trustees and I pledged to post his reply if he wishes to issue one directly here, so far he did not respond*


Because there are places in the world where you go to University in order to be taught and cultivated. You are treated with respect because only then will you have dignity. You are expected to speak your mind because only then will you have character. You engage in shaping your Institution, because you are a part of it.

Not so in the Guc. In the Guc, you are expected to listen humbly because otherwise you'll be too much of a bother. You are expected to accept insult in humility because only then will you show proper respect to the vanity of those above you. You are expected to be lied to like an idiot, dragged from office to office for the simple cause of demanding what you've paid for -- what your parents have worked hard and toiled and sacrificed hard to provide for you: an Education.

You are expected to beg and plead, You are expected to applaud condescending treatment. Why? They'll provide many explanations, but the truth is, for the past 8 years since its founding; each and every policy in the Guc had not been introduced for the welfare of the Student, but rather, for the comfort and profiteering of its Upper Management.

I say Upper Management and I mean the Owners, because everyone knows the University President is in this reality powerless, the reigns of leadership belong to the office of Ashraf Mansour, prime founder and chairman of G.U.C.

Not that I would've minded Dr. Mansour's leadership, if it was as he always claims 'for the love of country, knowledge and people'. I wouldn't have minded it if I haven't, for the past 7 years, seen young talents wasted; Students who's only aim was to learn and achieve, to do something. Seen Young people setting out early on the path of their life, only to hit a blocked road. A road where they learn from unlearned teachers, where their work's worth would be lost just because of one stupid regulation or policy Dr. Mansour has laid down on a whim.

They'd fail courses their Professors would've let them pass, that they were worthy enough to pass, only because they were good students but they were sick and the University's Medical Office was not convinced and called their excuse a Lie. Because their grandparent has died the night before the examination, but that, to Ashraf Mansour, was not a reason good enough: His student's troubles are never good enough if gets them out of repeating costly courses or paying for make-up exams or gets them out of being delayed behind in their studies and enriching the university with repeated semester fees. If it wastes the opportunity for more Money, its not good enough. This place is not about Education.

In some other institutions a lecturer holding a doctorate, the highest degree in the land, would be in charge of Education But this is not about Education, people, remember that! In some other institutions, this lecturer would take a class of 20, 30 students under his care. Would Mentor them, engage them in discussion, inspire and encourage their intellectual curiosity.

Not in the Guc. the Brochure might say 'small class sizes' but those are the classes taught by the secondary TA's, Teaching Assistants, not the doctorate holder. Rather, this one finds himself in a packed hall with anywhere from 300 to 50 students to dispose of quickly before moving on to the second and third course, where more packed halls and more unhappy students await, all sitting there frustrated of the waste of effort and time, because They don't can't understand.

I say dispose because yes, thats what the reality is in the Guc. Its not our Academic Staff's fault, but those Staff are not superhuman, they're overloaded, overworked, they take many more students and courses than any other respectable institution of similar resources assigns to its teachers. They're given burdens more than they can take.

Its not right to demand a newly graduate BSc holder, to tackle on the responsibilities of teaching a university level course, grade it, examine it - without giving them any training whatsoever in any one of those aspects, without giving them the Time to be able to pull it off even if they wanted! without giving them the Rewards which they are privy to. Guc TAs earn about 2200 LE a month, did you know that? Less than some primary school teachers, or call-center tellers, or many other Less-qualified professions.

Which means simply that the Guc's aim is to attract Less-qualfied talent than Primary school teachers. That'd be a joke if it wasn't tragic. Many good TA's stay at the Guc, either because they're graduates of this university and Sentimentality holds them to it, or they feel it beneficial for them to have a University Teaching stint on their resumes. Even so, the University should not exploit them this way. Besides, they stay temporarily and go. 

Many great and loved Professors had came to the Guc and left during my stay, they all resigned. Why? Because Ashraf Mansour pushed them to. Ashraf Mansour  had Vision, Ashraf Mansour had good Management. All Guc students agree that they hate their University's Policies, their University's System, the rules imposed by the Smartest-IT-Center-On-The-Earth. The Academic Staff hates it. But Ashraf Mansour insists. Why should one man's profit hold a whole institution down? A generation-after-generation of well-wishing students, the many Academics who have come to this university to uphold the mission of Learning and he wouldn't let them. Why?

On March 11th, Guc Students voiced their demands to Dr. Ashraf Mansour, they waited for hours for the reply they've been promised a week before by Dr. Ashraf Mansour, after being left out in the Sun with not even the slightest courtesy of a response, remember, this is Dr. Ashraf Mansour we're talking about: He's higher than having to respond to anyone. 


They shouted and screamed asking to see him. He did not agree.

He went as far as promising to meet them in H15 if they leave the vicinity of his office. He did not go down. 

He promised to see their representatives. He did not. He promised again to go down for a second time! Guess what? He broke his word for the second time. Is this Children's Play 'Le3b 3eyal'? I don't know whether to laugh or cry. In my humble opinion, that's not conduct becoming any man in position, let alone a University Chairman.

So Mr. Chairman, please tell me: Why would a University Chairman who cowards out from even talking to his Students, serve as a Chairman? Why would a University Chairman who failed and failed for 8 years to gain the approval the students and the academic staff of his institution, stay as its Chairman? Why would a Man who does not respect his Students, their Professors, or their Teachers -- Your external relations Manager shouted down a student for not saying 'Dr' before mentioning your name because it was 'lack of respect' -- Mr. Chairman, why would you stay as Chairman, and keep your University and the people its built on down, if you don't Respect them at all? Why, Chairman?



16 comments:

  1. msa 3al kalam , meya meya 3ayzeen neb3atha le germany , da eza kan el guc leha 3elaka be germany asln

    ReplyDelete
  2. b3'ad ennazar..i totally agree with your words..
    bas i feel like its a bit similar to the previous regime..m3 far2 en we own egypt..but we do not own guc :)
    i hope u understand what i mean..he's the owner..he could be a chairman as well..he'll do whatever he likes to do..unfortunately..they do not respect us :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is great !! But I have some suggestions if you intend to publish it or use it. Add more evidences, mention earlier attempts to complain, keda .. Let it address the mind and emotions of the readers .. (If you are intending to use it for such purposes .. )
    and one correction .. its 2l00 LE .. and its been so since GUC came to existence :) ..

    ReplyDelete
  4. What is this nonsense ?!!!!!!! May I ask how old are you ?! the person who wrote this nonsense article filled with personal prejudice, hear-say and unbased speculation !!!!!!!! please wake up people this is not a revolution against what exactly against education and universities if that is so then God help us all!! welcome to anarchy and stupidity !!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. مؤسسة جمع أموال فقط لا غير .. و ليست مؤسسة تعليمية

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  7. As a former TA and student at the GUC, I agree with you. I spent 5 years as a student and witnessed many weird things, and I thought after starting my job as a TA that things wouldn't get worse... I was SO wrong!

    Proof of the IT's incompetence can be shown in the following:
    - The first class I ever taught as a TA was scheduled in another TA's office... Some of the other TA's had their classes scheduled in bathrooms...
    - In 2 years the desktop computers they provided me had 3 hardware failures (not to mention that they had a terrible hardware configuration to start with)...
    - Students had courses dropped even though I had marked them as "Attended" in all their tutorials...
    - I sometimes had to enter grades twice, because I had the same group twice on the system and didn't know which one would be kept and which one would be deleted.
    - Advising students had to wait for the IT department to unlock courses, open tutorial slots to be assigned to their schedules, fix problems with elective courses... One student had his schedule finalized a week before the midterms!
    - On several occasions, I was unable to enter any grades or attendance because there was some problem with the server... After the problem gets fixed a few days later, I find the attendance sessions locked with everyone marked as "Absent"!

    I could go on and on... I also could mention many more problems with this God-forsaken place, but that would take a VERY long time.

    I respect this article, and I hope it can aid your cause...

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great article, I agree with every point. I curse the day I applied for admission in this university. I was pretty psyched to join the GUC after seeing the campus, brochure, the video they play in the admission area lol, but that was all fake advertising to attract people. There are a lot of things that piss me off in this place especially the huge amount of money I pay for repeated hours. I never understood this policy because it doesn't make any freaking sense, I already pay the semester fees, why do I then need to pay extra fees for repeated hours if the number of credit hours I will be taking during the semester are within the allowed limit. Same thing with the students doing their bachlors in Germany, why do they have to pay for the semester fees if they will not be attending any courses on campus, these are all things that prove to me that GUC is just hungry for money. What pisses me off even more is that they aren't using a fraction of that money for the students' benefit, just pay a visit to the library and see the very limited number of books there, computer labs have the crappiest computers with lots of hardware and software failures, the list goes on. Instead they spend that money on welcome parties, fertilizers, lawns, and other very useless things such as Wifi in the buses, digital media campus which just playing music all day long, the list goes on. I am almost out of that God forsaken place and I honestly regret the day I joined the GUC, I could have used that money and joined a university abroad where i would have received a much better university experience.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I agree with most of your points. I think I only disagree with doctorate lecturers point. Professors can lecture 50-200 students, that is not a problem. However, there should be groups for those who are interested in the topics of the lecturer to the lecturer to mentor them. Highly qualified TAs are sufficient for tutorials. We had and still have many qualified TAs in the GUC. But, they always resign after a while.

    I agree with you that the management is not competent. The GUC earns tens of millions every year but it is not reflecting on the GUC staff or students in better academic or social quality.

    If we assume that GUC serves 3000 Makeup every summer (This is a low estimation), if the makeup is for 1500 EGP average (1st and 2nd makeups average) This means 4.5 million EGP every summer. This extra budget that is not supposed to happen (Makeups shall not enter the budget because university shall not expect students to fail), this extra budget has to be used recruiting qualified staff and financially satisfying them

    ReplyDelete
  10. Nobody forced u to join, although u have the chance every moment to leave and u didn't. Face it its not a charity learning institution, if u want one please leave.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I like ur comment & agree with U

    Spyman said...

    Nobody forced u to join, although u have the chance every moment to leave and u didn't. Face it its not a charity learning institution, if u want one please leave>
    & I add
    This s exactly the wrongway to deal with Ur personal problems

    ReplyDelete
  12. Ahmed said:

    b3'ad ennazar..i totally agree with your words..
    bas i feel like its a bit similar to the previous regime..m3 far2 en we own egypt..but we do not own guc :)
    i hope u understand what i mean..he's the owner..he could be a chairman as well..he'll do whatever he likes to do..unfortunately..they do not respect us :)

    I somewhat agree with ur comment, we do not own the GUC literally that's true, but think about it, the GUC only strives upon the students fees and the students attending in general, if all of us never existed, the GUC would have been nothing but just vacant gay pink buildings. So at one point we do own the GUC all together, it's a shared property since we pay money to learn there.

    One of the Anons said:

    What is this nonsense ?!!!!!!! May I ask how old are you ?! the person who wrote this nonsense article filled with personal prejudice, hear-say and unbased speculation !!!!!!!! please wake up people this is not a revolution against what exactly against education and universities if that is so then God help us all!! welcome to anarchy and stupidity !!!!!!

    mesh 7a2olak 3'ier enak qela mondasa :P

    @Spyman: if leaving was that easy, no would had a problem, but try to convince my family who had paid thousands of money for the last 3 years just to leave and put all that money to waste, good luck with that.

    ReplyDelete
  13. For the people who are against this article, I don't think that the post was out of revenge or personal benefits, if the professors agree as well as the TAs, and the students, then how come this is nonsense, no one asked from the university to be charitable, people are asking the university to be reasonable with its policy, with their conduct towards the students, and I don't think that what is written is personal problems but I rather think that many students have the same point of view. Its not about the age, no one is old enough to judge the others!!

    ReplyDelete
  14. I graduated in 2007 and trust me when I say it got pretty shit when we left..It WAS alright when we started out..not a lot of students; hence we did have a "mentoring" experience..I knew professors on a first hand basis and they knew us...whether it being professors from my faculty or others. Life on campus was chilled...but then it all went down the drain! They got greedy..any retard could apply and get a teaching job, all the good caliber professors left because they couldn't deal with the bullshit.

    My graduating class was a mere handful..the rest had transferred out or simply failed and carried on studying at Guc..we were the lab rats they used to introduce and tweak courses..we got shafted in every way you can imagine..people who passed all their courses were told "You didn't pass Maths 101 in 2003"...on their night of graduation, EXPLAIN THAT MOM AND DAD....

    I graduated 4 years ago and guess what? We don't have an alumni..We don't have rights, I don't feel I BELONG there..it makes you wish you went to some other under the bridge University atleast you wouldn't have paid so much. It makes you wish you went to the AUC when instead you CHOSE GUC because it seemed "NICER". And when we tried to transfer out to AUC, they just made it hard and pointless, they wouldn't accept GUCians because in their opinion "GUC is Unaccredited, so we can't accept ANY of your courses. You'll have to go back to being a FRESHMAN". SERIOUSLY?!?! I know people that have left GUC, and have yet to graduated they are well in their late 20's..some married with children! But that's what it does to you..it takes your money and chews you out.

    I never thought of joining their "Masters Program" because it's BULLSHIT! You merely take on a "third major" and write a thesis about something else. For example: I double majored in Finance and Economics, I wanted a Masters in Finance, they said I couldn't take Finance as a course for my Masters program but instead i could choose a different major and write my masters thesis in FINANCE!!! Are you serious?!

    I truly feel that i learned ALOT because of previous qualified professors, however I WOULD NEVER ENROLL MY CHILDREN THERE..

    As for Ashraf Mansour replying to you..I'm sorry my friend, but that shall never happen for he is as bad, maybe worse than Hosny Mubarak. The only way you can speak to him is to have be "wasel" or simply catch him off guard when he speaks to he parents during his "welcoming speech" and just rape him on the spot!

    Sincerely,
    M.A

    ReplyDelete
  15. أنا بقول للناس إلي بتقول إن ده قضية شخصية إن لأ ده قضية في منتهى الصحة و ملهاش أي دعوة بالشخصية ده قضية كل طالب في الجامعة الألمانيه يا جماعة مين هنا طالب ولا دكتور ينكر إن ده أحد أكتر الأماكن في مصر بل في العالم إلي مليانة بيروقراطية و نظام موظفين حكومة و مليانة كوسة و مليانة وسايط زي إن ولاد ناس معينة و ممكن أقول عليهم بالإسم إتعينو فالجامعة علطول، مين يقدر ينكر إن الإمكانية المتاحة للطلبة متمشيش أبداً مع حجم الطلبة ولا مع كمية الاختصاصات إلي هما بيدرسوها، يعني مثلاً القسم بتاع هندسة المواد في الجامعة المفروض يكون بيستغل المصانع لكن للأسف عشان أعمل اى حاجة في المصنع محتاج لإذن من المهندس عصام حمودة، طب إفرض إنو بقى المهندس مسافر زي أما حصل في حالتي أنا لأني كنت عايز إمضاؤه و هو كان مسافر في ألمانيا ، أطر أنا إن أنا استنه 25 يوم عقبال أما يرجع من ألمانيا، ليه أنا استنى، ؟؟
    دة ناهيك عن إن أنا أصلاً لم حتى رحتلهم هناك معرفتش أعمل إلي أنا عايزة عشان كل مجيب حاجة تبئة غير مطابقة للمواصفات، طب أنا عايز أفهم، إيه هي المواصفات و مكتوبة فين و مين إلي حطها، انما طبعاً محدش يرد علينا عشان احنا مش بنأدمين بالنسبه لهم، و بعدين ييجي واحد يقول ده مش قضية على الطلبة كلهم ده شخصية، لأ طبعاً ده أدي تخص كل طالب ، لما أنا أروح أخد إذن من حد على حاجة أترمي برة زي الكلب على إعتبار إن أنا مش انسان مثلاً ، و بعدين يا جماعة المضحك فالحوار إن كل الأجهزة إلي فالجامعة ده تبرعات مش دافعين هما فيه حاجة، و بيفهمو الجماعة الاجانب إلي بييجو كل فترة إن ده بتستخدم أحسن إستخدام ، تعرفو إن مصانع الجامعة إلي المفروض لينا احنا الطلبة، بيعمل في قطع غيار و بيشغلوها لحساب الجامعة، و يا ريت بنستفيد منها احنا حاجة ، وبعدين ييجي حد يقوللي شخصية ، ده قضية كل انسان عند مخ دخل الجامعة ده، وأظن انكم فاكرين الموضوع إلي نزل في الأهرام من سنتين مين ينكر إلي كان مكتوب فيه عن مشاكل في جداول بتنزل متأخر شهر و شهرين يا جماعة والله مكان بيبقى عندي جدول لمدة شهرين، و المسؤول مين معرفش ومحدش عايز يقلنا ، أكيد الآي تي البايظ إلي عندنا.

    و بعدين بقى يا جماعة أنا بدرس قانون دلوقتي في معهد الدراسات الدبلوماسية و أقدر أقول لكم إن بكل وسيلة قانونية ممكنة و يمكن ليكم انكم تسألو على الكلام دة أي محامي في العالم يقول لكم إن الجامعة الألمانية تقع تحت طائلة القانون بموجب القاعدة القانونية إلي بتقول إنو يعاقب كل من ساهم في عملية بيع أو في المساعدة في أي عملية بيع حتى لو كان هذا البيع مشروع، يعاقب كل من إرتكب واحد من إثنين من هذه أشياء:

    قاعدة الغلط
    قاعدة الغش
    قاعدة التدليس
    الغلط هو انك تكون فاهم شئ غلط و تشتري الشء على أساس فهمك الخاطئ، و الغلط يقع على عاتق المشتري مثلاً أن تشتري سيارة وأنت لا تفهم أن بها عيباً كونك أنت لست ميكانيكياً وساعتها يبقى الغلط عليك كونك لم تتحرى .

    ولكن أن يأتي أحد ويقوم بإعلان غير صحيح وفيه تشويه لباطن الأمور وفيه إلتفاف على الحقائق كأن تقوم الجامعة الألمانية بإعلان أن نصف الطاقم التدريسي الأكاديمي هم من الألمان، وهذا ليس صحيحاً، أو أن يقول أن عدد الطالبة في الفصول محدود وهو ليس محدود، فهذا يقع تحت طائلة القانون بموجب الغش والتدليس ولو ثبت ذلك يحق لكل من تضرر يحق له التعويض وذلك لأنه تم عملية غش منظمة ضده .

    وأحب أن أشير إلا أن من يقول أن من يريد أن يمشي لماذا لم يمشي، ، السبب بسيط، وهو أن ليس يوجد من يعترف بلمواد التي درسناها في الجامعة وليس من المعقول أن أترك بعد عام أضعته من حياتي وأنا ادرس وادفع وكثيراً منا لا يستطيع دفع تلك الأموال الباهظة مرةً أخرى، إذاً فهذا ليس معقولاً أبداً.

    ومن قال اننا دخلنا باختيارنا فنعم دخلنا ولكن بناءً على تدليس ومعلومات مضللة ومثلاً على ذلك أن تشتري شيئاً يقال لك أنه سليم(سيارة سليمة مثلاً) فتنتفي عنه صفات الصحة حين تجده مليئاً بالعيوب هل يمكن أن تسألني حينئذٍ لماذا اشتريت ، لا يمكن ، لأنه كان هناك خداع.

    ويقع أيضاً في ضمن الغش والتدليس أنهم قالوا إن الشهادة من ألمانيا وانها تعطى بعد أربع سنين وأن المواد المدروسة معادلة في ألمانيا، ومن منا يرى أن هذا صحيح ؟ وطبعاً هذا غير صحيح بتاتاً ولم يحدث على الاطلاق.

    وشكراً

    ReplyDelete
  16. I couldnt agree more with what is said. It feels a little vindictive but then we all have a right to be feel a little vindictive. Applause and respect !!

    ReplyDelete